For Online E-newspaper
Daily Nation : February 4th 2014
8 smart company Tuesday February 4, 2014 DAILY NATION cover OUTLOOK» AS BANKS START TO RELEASE THEIR FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE REPORTS FOR 2013, CONCERN IS GROWING ON THE C Harsh land laws force banks to rethink lending There has been little progress in attempts to have the contentious sections of the laws amended BY RAMENYA GIBENDI email@example.com @ramenyag A the Land Act. The section makes it man- stalled law reform touch- ing on land that bankers and financial institutions were pushing has forced a change of strategy that could see a shift in evaluating and securing loans. The bankers’ umbrella body, Kenya Bankers Association, said last year that it had proposed amendments to the legislation owing to what it termed as legal limitations arising from the Land Act, Land Registration Act, and the National Land Commission Act enacted in 2010. But the umbrella body’s boss, Mr Habil Olaka, says there has been little progress in attempts to have the contentious sections of the laws amended. “The proposed amendments are still with the technical committee, which is analysing all the technicalities that the legislation presents to the industry,” he said. The amendments were ren- dered urgent following a ruling by the High Court last year that barred Equity Bank from auctioning property to recover money from a loan defaulter. Collaterised asset The law, which came into force in May 2012, requires banks selling a defaulter’s property to do so at the highest possible market value and, upon receiving the proceeds, deduct whatever the borrower owes and remit the rest to the property owner. Previously, there had been no legal requirement on lenders to recover any amounts from the sale of a collateralised asset above the outstanding loan amounts, leaving helpless borrowers at the risk of losing their entire investment even after servicing part of the loan. In the case of Equity Bank, for instance, the court stopped the public sale of a defaulter’s property, saying the bank had failed to comply with Section 97(2) of 2012 datory for the lender to give a defaulter at least 90 additional days to redeem the outstanding amount after the expiry of a sale notice, an action that sent shock waves in the industry and prompted KBA to act. KBA says the complexities are indeed a challenge to lenders, considering that most banks rely on collateral to give loans. Bankers feel that certain sec- tions of the land laws grant their customers the power to recover assets auctioned by a financial institution due to a default. “It is our view that such agree- ments should be governed by the contract signed between the two parties and not be defined by legislation,” said KBA in an earlier interview. The bankers want an amend- ment to Section 79 (3) of the Land Act that provides that the consent of the spouse be obtained when auctioning matrimonial property. Matrimonial property KBA feels that the law itself is vague on what matrimonial property is and how such property is to be treated if the parties are married but live separately, just as it is not clear for cases of civil or polygamous marriages since there is no marriage registry in the country. The Land Act also requires that banks to involve tenants and other guarantors before selling the property that was used as collateral for a loan, a requirement that may make banks shy away from title deeds as collateral. Experts say that indeed banks have to act as the new land legislation drastically limits their powers. “This will indeed be a night- mare to banks but it puts to an end cases where husbands clandestinely sold matrimonial property using fake wives without the knowledge of their real spouses,” said Mr Harold Ayodo, an advocate of the High Court. He said a polygamous man is required to obtain consent Year when the law requiring banks selling a defaulter’s property to do so at the highest possible market price came into place. The law also requires banks to remit to the property owner the remainder of the money after the dues are deducted from all his wives before using a title deed as collateral since any transactions done without the consent of all spouses are illegal and have no basis under the Act. Facing a headwind, the bank- ers want to accelerate the shift to character-based lending, which puts more weight on borrower’s history than securities. The Association of Kenya Credit Providers (AKCP) is in the final stages of launching phase two of the credit information sharing regime that now brings on board deposit-taking microfinance (DTM) institutions in sharing information across all lending institutions. “Phase II, which involves both positive and negative information, also known as full file data, will be rolled out in this first quarter,” said Mr Jared Getenga, interim chief executive officer of AKCP. KBA had already indicated that it would be banking on the credit information sharing initiative, which introduces characterbased lending as an alternative for credit providers to shift from security-based lending upon enactment of the necessary regulations. Under the Credit Reference Bureau Regulations 2013, banks will be able to share comprehensive data on a customer’s credit history and CBK-licensed credit reference bureaus (CRB) can develop risk assessment products for banks to better price loans. The Credit Reference Bureau FILE | NATION New laws require banks selling a defaulter’s property to do so at the highest possible market value and, upon receiving the proceeds, to deduct whatever is owed and remit the rest to the property owner. HOW BANKS AWARD CREDIT SCORE Regulations 2013 were thus gazetted on January 17 last year, mandating banks to share both positive and negative data on their loans, enabling good borrowers access to cheaper loans. In phase one, banks only shared negative information about borrowers, helping them avoid lending to serial defaulters. “As lenders get accustomed When banks were mandated to share positive information with credit reference bureaus following an amendment to the Central Bank of Kenya Act early last year, the credit score was said to range between 100 and 900, with a score of between 100 and 400 indicating a possible defaulter. A score of 401 to 600 indicates one has not defaulted but their level of debt to income is considered high, and thus treated as fair. A score of 700 to 800 is good, while above 800 is excellent, and indicates prompt payments and long credit history. A person who has no credit record is not awarded a credit score. to applying credit scores in risk management, the focus on tangible collateral, e.g. land and buildings, will diminish in the medium term,” said Mr Getenga. Mr Getenga, however, said that currently, the thrust is on banks and DTMs because the new regulations do not cover other lenders like saccos, which are expected to be brought on board in phase three. Agency model The CRB regulations have made it easy for borrowers to access credit reference bureau services by making a provision for them to introduce the agency model. Currently, the only two li- censed CRBs, Metropol CRB and Transunion CRB, operate in Nairobi and are expected to serve the whole nation. “It also provides for en- hanced consumer protection mechanisms such as issuance of pre-listing notices to borrowers before they are listed in the case of a default,” explained Mr Getenga.
February 3rd 2014
February 5th 2014